Penelope Trunk gave out some very bad advice. The more I think about it, the more I object to it. The article is so egregious that it is difficult to limit myself to a single quote, but here is a sample:
The majority of twentysomethings today move back home with their parents , job hop every 18 months, and refuse to pay their dues.
And you know what? These are all good decisions. To you, these decisions might look like decisions that losers make, but the world is different.
You know, the world isn’t really that different. A little different, yes, but different enough to make those good decisions? No.
Normally, I would say that we all have different viewpoints and let’s agree to disagree. But in this case, here is a respected columnist giving out what looks to me like a recipe for failure, depression, and limited opportunities later on in life.
I’m 46 years old, engaged in typical middle-aged ruminations over what I did right and what I did wrong in my youth. When I look back, I don’t think, “I wish I had more fun when I was young”. Instead, I say, “I wish I worked harder when I was young.” You know how they say that you should start investing young, because the money you invest will compound and amount to much more in the future than that same amount of money invested later? It’s the same for other things. The amount of work you put into your career, the amount of learning you do, the contacts you make, the projects you accomplish, the skills you acquire – these all provide the basis for everything you do later in life. You can’t make up that lost time later.
Coincidentally, I am at this time engaged in reading Golden Steps to Respectability, written by John Mather Austin, published in 1850, downloaded from Project Gutenberg. Austin says:
If the young would have their career honorable and prosperous–if they would enjoy the respect and confidence of community; if they would have the evening of their days calm, serene, and peaceful–they must prepare for it early in life. They must lay “a good foundation against the time to come”–a foundation which will be capable of sustaining the edifice they would erect.
So much for “the world is different”.
Another exerpt from Austin:
Respectability, prosperity, the good opinion of community, do not come simply at our bidding. We cannot reach forth our hands and take them, as we pluck the ripe fruit from the bending branch. Neither will wishing or hoping for them shower their blessings upon us. If we would obtain and _enjoy_ them, we must _labor_ for them–EARN them. They are only secured as the well-merited reward of a pure and useful life!
When you are twenty, you don’t want to hear such stodgy advice – I didn’t want to hear it – but it’s true.
What I would say to a twenty year old is this: Some day you will be a 45 year old person. Imagine yourself. Where will you be in life? What will you be doing? What kind of job do you want? Will you be working at a big company, a small company, self-employed? How are you going to get there? Will you be married? Will you have children? How many? What kind of hobbies would you like to have? Would you like to be able to travel? What kind of house will you live in? Now ask yourself – what kind of gift can you as a twenty year old give to your forty five year old self? What action can you take today that your older self will look back upon and say, “Thank you, young self!” Now, do it. Take that class. Save that money. Finish that project. Stay in touch with that friend.
Isn’t it cool to think you can give yourself a gift across time?
4 Comments
What you’re saying is exactly Penelope’s point: you define success one way (i.e., having invested money early) but others can define it another way. She’s simply saying allow children to define for themselves what success is. Just like you said, no 20 year old is going to listen to ’sound advice’ anyway. Let them figure out who they are just like you did.
I am an example of choosing a career at 22 out of fright. Now 52, I am burned out, scared, with no other skills. Let the 20 somethings go out and figure it out but let them know you love them and your advise is there for them, don’t be afraid to give it to them and most of all if you lead your 20 something with good example(i guarantee i am glad i don’t have kids seeing me this way)trully good example they’ll reap it.
Man
Do I agree with you!! I read her article. Then I read it again. And I STILL could not believe the amount of horseshit that was written.
Hey, if your just graduating from high school and want to spend the next 30 years wandering around, always looking for what makes you HAPPY, bouncing from one job to the next, refusing to get “caught up in the rat race”, take this article to heart.
And you will be sitting there at 48, shaking your head, thinking about nothing but:
SHOULDA’S, COULDA’S, WOULDA’S.
Nothing, NOTHING, sucks more than REGRET. And believe me, THATS what youre gonna have.
I think that, as with most things, both of these pieces of advice have the potential to be taken in the wrong light. I am 26 and have spent the vast majority of my twenties traveling, job hopping, partying, and engaging in pursuits that may be enriching (I taught myself motorcycle repair) but certainly not for my “career” whatever that may be. On the other hand I worked for Apple Computer for two years as a top-level support agent, I’ve worked for another year as a set decorator for movies with an art department crew, I spent six months with a school district as a mac technical specialist, then I went on a 3 month motorcycle trip across the US and landed in South Korea teaching English for a year. I have no money, no idea what I am going to do with my life, tons and TONS of AMAZING friends, an extremely broad skill set with the flexibility to focus on any area of it at a moments notice, dozens of awesome stories of danger and adventure, and a pretty solid idea of what I DON’T want in a career. Not to mention a resume that usually gets me at least an interview simply because of how random my experience is. It makes employers curious. So on the one hand, and I may be blowing smoke here, since I AM only 26, I don’t think the answer is to move back in with parents, unless in case of dire emergency, but on the other hand getting on a fast track to one career also seems like a blunder.